It was made out of crap materials and crap welds. I estimate the wheel hop/pinion bouncing ripped it more then a launch on stickys on the track. I bought the entire sub-frame with an S4 diff attached to it so I just bolted the entire thing in since it seemed like a good design at the time. It actually made the wheel hop die down quite a bit, but I think the better way to mount it would be a bolt through design with some inserts to strengthen the attachment point on the rear sub frame. Similar to the way hinson uses inserts on his FC pedestal mounts. That way you wouldn't risk tearing the sheet metal off.
I think your design is definitely the right direction to go for the FC pinion mount, but I was just letting you know about the experience I had with welding directly to the sheet metal on the subframe.
There are a few reasons that can cause the lower / horizontal bar to tear away from the crossmember.
- If the bar is too short, and does not reach back far enough, to provide the leverage that is required to keep it from "teeter - tottering", on the front edge of the crossmember
- If the bar is not welded all the way around, including the front and rear edges. It can cause a stress riser, which could easily start a tear at that point
- If the weld was undercut into the stamped metal, causing it to be thinner at that point
- if you had the above things going on, and your original pinion mount was doing little to nothing, to hold the front secure.
3fingerwilly ran one that was nowhere near as beefy as this one, and never had any issues. Granted, he has an automatic, and minimal wheel hop.
There you have it, a few different executions of the same idea. Some functioned correctly, while another failed.
We have had endless threads on controlling FC wheel hop.
One of the best solutions, if not the best, is the AWR lateral rods ( not sure what they are called in the Mazda manual) that AndrewB was running on his car.